Elizabeth Gilbert pulls new novel after outcry over Russian setting
Listen 4 min Comment on this story Comment Gift Article Share
Elizabeth Gilbert, the best-selling author of “Eat, Pray, Love” and other books, said Monday that she would pull her upcoming novel, “The Snow Forest,” from publication following outcries online about its Russian setting. She announced her decision in a video posted to her Twitter, Instagram and Facebook accounts.
Gilbert cited “an enormous, massive outpouring of reactions and responses from my Ukrainian readers, expressing anger, sorrow, disappointment and pain about the fact that I would choose to release a book into the world right now, any book, no matter what the subject of it is, that is set in Russia.” As a result, she said, “I am making a course correction and I am removing the book from its publication schedule.”
“The Snow Forest,” which was scheduled to be published on Feb. 13, 2024, was inspired by the true story of a religious Russian family who, in the 1930s, left Russia for a life of extreme solitude in Siberia, only to be discovered decades later by Soviet geologists, according to Gilbert’s publisher, Riverhead Books. Gilbert has described the characters as deciding to “remove themselves from society to resist the Soviet government and to try to defend nature against industrialization.” In a video message to her fans last week, Gilbert said, “This is a book that is going to take you into the deepest realms of the Siberian taiga, and into the heart and mind of an extraordinary girl born into that world, a girl of great spiritual and creative talent, raised far, far, far from everything that we call normal.”
Advertisement
“The Snow Forest” currently has an average one-star rating on Goodreads, with hundreds posting comments since June 10 criticizing Gilbert for romanticizing Russian culture. “It looks like Elizabeth Gilbert herself ‘lived isolated and undetected’ last few years. Because how else can you explain publishing an ‘inspiring story’ about russians, while they are committing genocide against Ukrainians at this moment?” one reviewer wrote. Others pointed out that the announced publication date fell close to the second anniversary of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Important announcement about THE SNOW FOREST. Please note that if you were charged for your pre-order, you will be fully refunded. Thank you so much. pic.twitter.com/OAEmrjtfJx — Elizabeth Gilbert (@GilbertLiz) June 12, 2023
Gilbert’s announcement received a mixed reception on social media: Dozens thanked and praised Gilbert for what they called a “brave” decision, and for her integrity and empathy; others expressed skepticism.
“Putin’s Russia is a far right imperialist and terrorist state that deserves all the opprobrium directed at it. But this seems very weird to me. I mean the author’s decision but … no book should be set in historical Russia now?” novelist and critic Lincoln Michel said on Twitter. “A novel about people resisting the USSR no less? Huh?”
Advertisement
“Fully respect any author’s right to voluntarily withdraw their own title from publication, but this feels like an absurd over correction, and I’m baffled that it was called for in the first place,” author and journalist Otegha Uwagba wrote.
“It presents sort of a logical conundrum,” Keith Gessen, a Russian-born journalist and novelist wrote over email. “If the book is good, and teaches us things about Russia and the Russian past that we didn’t know — and why else would you write a book set in Russia, if you weren’t trying to do that? — then it’s a bad decision to pull it. But if the book is not good, and uses Russia, as some American authors have done over the years, as a kind of romantic place of History and Tragedy, then it’s an honorable decision. But without having read the book it’s impossible to know which one of these it is.
“In general, though, I don’t have a problem with writers thinking about how their book will be read, or what it is saying politically. Just because it’s fiction doesn’t mean it doesn’t have ideas, or values, or won’t affect people. I think as a writer you have to believe that it does and it will.”
Advertisement
Other writers have received similar pressure after announcing books about Russia. Following Gilbert’s announcement, some Twitter users renewed their pressure on Nora Krug, who in August will publish a graphic memoir, “Diaries of War,” adapting her correspondence with a Ukrainian journalist and a Russian artist, which grew out of a series of op-eds originally published in the Los Angeles Times. The posts accused her of “whitewashing Russians” and of “spreading propaganda,” and demanded that she not proceed with the book. Krug did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Gilbert said on social media that she will now turn her attention to other book projects and that anyone charged for a preorder would be refunded.
Reached for comment, she declined to elaborate further. A representative from Riverhead also declined to comment, except to say that the novel had been “delayed indefinitely.”
This story has been updated.
GiftOutline Gift Article
A note to our readers We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Source: The Washington Post
